A copper wire and a piece of pure (intrinsic) silicon, both at 300 K, are heated to 350 K. Which of the following correctly describes the change in their resistances and the reason?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 7 of 80
A copper wire and a piece of pure (intrinsic) silicon, both at 300 K, are heated to 350 K.
- Correct answer
(A) Copper: rises slightly, because the number of free electrons stays the same while they are scattered more often. Silicon: falls sharply, because many more electron-hole pairs are generated.
(B) Copper: falls slightly, because more free electrons are released. Silicon: rises sharply, because the carriers are scattered more often.
(C) Both rise, because in both the carriers are scattered more often at higher temperature.
(D) Both fall, because in both more carriers are set free at higher temperature.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: In copper the conduction band is partly filled, so the number of free electrons is fixed and very large, and it does not change with temperature. Heating makes the ions vibrate more, so the electrons are scattered more often. The resistance of copper therefore rises slightly, by roughly 20 % for a 50 K rise.
In intrinsic silicon the free carriers are the electron-hole pairs created by thermal energy across the 1.1 eV gap. The number of such pairs rises very steeply with temperature, roughly 25 times between 300 K and 350 K. This increase in the number of carriers far outweighs the extra scattering, so the resistance of silicon falls sharply.

- (B) swaps the behaviours of the two materials.
- (C) is true for copper but ignores the huge rise in the number of carriers in silicon.
- (D) is true for silicon but copper has no reservoir of extra carriers to set free.
