Carbon, silicon, germanium and tin are all in group IV and all have the same kind of outer electron arrangement. Their energy gaps are 5.4 eV, 1.1 eV, 0.7 eV and 0 eV respectively. Which statement correctly explains why tin behaves as a metal?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 21 of 80
Carbon, silicon, germanium and tin are all in group IV and all have the same kind of outer electron arrangement.
(A) Tin has more valence electrons per atom than silicon, so it has more free electrons.
- Correct answer
(B) In tin the valence band and the conduction band have no gap between them, so electrons can move into empty conduction states with almost no energy.
(C) Tin atoms are heavier, so their outer electrons are held so loosely that each atom loses all four.
(D) Tin has a very large gap, so electrons cannot fall back into the valence band once they have been freed.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: Whether a solid conducts well is decided by whether its electrons can reach empty energy states. In C, Si and Ge a forbidden gap separates the full valence band from the empty conduction band, and the gap falls from 5.4 eV to 1.1 eV to 0.7 eV down the group. In tin the gap has closed to 0 eV: the bands touch, so even at very low temperature there are empty states immediately above the filled ones. Electrons move into them with almost no energy and a large number of them are free to carry current, just as in a metal.

- (A) is wrong because all four elements have four valence electrons.
- (C) is wrong because metallic conduction does not come from each atom losing all its valence electrons; it comes from the absence of a gap.
- (D) describes an insulator, not a metal. A large gap would leave practically no electrons freed at room temperature.
