A proton of kinetic energy 1 MeV aimed at a nucleus is turned back before it touches the nucleus. A neutron of only about 0.03 eV can reach the same nucleus and cause fission. Give the precise reason.
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 47 of 80
A proton of kinetic energy 1 MeV aimed at a ²35 ₉2 U nucleus is turned back before it touches the nucleus.
Concept used — the Coulomb barrier
A charged particle approaching a nucleus of charge is repelled. To reach the nuclear surface it must bring in at least the electrostatic potential energy at contact,
where is the distance between the centres when the two just touch. A neutral particle () has : there is no barrier for it.
Step 1 — The neutron. The neutron has no charge, so it feels no Coulomb repulsion from the 92 protons of uranium. However slowly it moves, nothing pushes it back; it drifts up to the nucleus until the short-range attractive nuclear force captures it, and the nucleus can then undergo fission.
Step 2 — The proton: distance at contact. Using the standard values with fm (not given in the question), the uranium radius is fm and the proton radius is fm, so
Step 3 — The proton: height of the barrier. With , C and N m² C⁻²:
A 1 MeV proton has far less energy than this, so it is stopped and turned back well before it touches the nucleus.
Answer: the neutron is uncharged, so there is no Coulomb barrier for it and even a 0.03 eV neutron reaches the nucleus; the proton is charged and must climb a Coulomb barrier of about 15 MeV, far more than its 1 MeV.
