Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: (i) A neutral 1327Al atom has Z=13 electrons:
26.98153913×0.000549×100 %=26.980.00714×100 %=0.026 %
(ii) Binding energy of the nucleus (13 protons, 14 neutrons):
Δm=13(1.007825)+14(1.008665)−26.981539=0.241496 u,Eb=0.241496×931.5=225 MeV
Rest energy of the electrons =13×0.511=6.64 MeV, and
2256.64×100 %=3.0 %
The electrons carry a tiny share of the mass, but their rest energy is not small compared with nuclear binding energies. That is why the electrons must always be balanced when atomic masses are used to find Q.
- (A) counts one electron only: 0.0020 % and 2250.511=0.23 %.
- (B) counts one electron per nucleon (27 electrons): 0.055 % and 22527×0.511=6.1 %. The number of electrons is Z, not A.
- (D) gets (ii) right but multiplies the fraction 2.6×10−4 in (i) by 104 instead of 100.