Answer: (D) The Assertion is false, but the Reason is true.
The Assertion is false. For numbers, x2=1 does force x=1 or x=−1, but matrices have many more square roots of the identity. A single counterexample settles it:
A=[100−1]⟹A2=[1001]=I,
yet A is neither I nor −I. Another is A=[0110], which also squares to I.
The reason the numerical argument fails is that it relies on factorising x2−1=(x−1)(x+1) and then concluding that one factor must vanish. For matrices, (A−I)(A+I)=O does not force A−I=O or A+I=O: a product of two non-zero matrices can be the zero matrix.
The Reason is true. Associativity, (XY)Z=X(YZ), is one of the standard properties of matrix multiplication. It is simply unrelated to the false claim in the Assertion.