Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 79 of 80
A snooker player wants to send the cue ball from A to strike a red ball at B by bouncing it once off a straight cushion.
Question 795 marksHard
A snooker player wants to send the cue ball from A to strike a red ball at B by bouncing it once off a straight cushion. Measured in units of 10 cm, A is 2 units from the cushion and B is 4 units from it, on the same side, and the feet M and N of the perpendiculars from A and B to the cushion are 15 units apart. The ball strikes the cushion at a point P between M and N with MP=x, so PN=15−x. The incoming path AP and the outgoing path PB make the angles
∠APM=tan−1x2,∠BPN=tan−115−x4
with the cushion. A ball bounces off a cushion so that these two angles are equal.
Attempt any four of the following five sub-questions.
(a) Find the bounce point, that is, the value of x for which ∠APM=∠BPN.
(b) For this bounce point, find the angle ∠APB between the incoming and outgoing paths, first in the form π−tan−1k and then as a value of cos−1.
(c) A beginner aims at the point Q on the cushion with MQ=6 instead. The ball leaves Q at an angle to the cushion equal to its incoming angle. Find, as a single inverse tangent, the angle between the path the ball actually takes after Q and the path QB that would have reached the red ball.
(d) For a general point P with 0<x<15, explain why
∠APB=π−tan−1x2−tan−115−x4
and find every x for which ∠APB is a right angle.
(e) Show that, as x increases from 0 to 15, ∠APM keeps decreasing while ∠BPN keeps increasing. Use this to explain why the bounce point found in (a) is the only one.
(a)tan−1 is one-one, so the two angles are equal exactly when their tangents are equal:
x2=15−x4⟺2(15−x)=4x⟺30=6x⟺x=5
The bounce point P is 5 units from M and 10 units from N, and both angles equal tan−152.
(b) At P the angles ∠APM, ∠APB and ∠BPN together make the straight angle along the cushion, so
∠APB=π−2tan−152
Let β=tan−152. Since 0<52<1, β∈(0,4π) and 2β∈(0,2π), with
Since ∠APB lies in [0,π], the principal branch of cos−1, we get ∠APB=cos−1(−2921). (Note 202+212=292.)
(c) At Q the incoming angle is ∠AQM=tan−162=tan−131, so the ball leaves at tan−131 to the cushion, heading towards N. The path to the red ball would need ∠BQN=tan−115−64=tan−194. Since 94>31, the needed path is steeper, and the angle between the two paths is
(This uses tan−1x−tan−1y=tan−11+xyx−y for x,y>0.) The ball runs too flat: by the time it is level with B it is only 9×31=3 units from the cushion, and misses the red ball, which is 4 units out.
(d)M and N lie on opposite sides of P on the straight cushion, so the angles ∠APM, ∠APB and ∠BPN fill the straight angle at P and add up to π. This gives the stated formula.
∠APB=2π exactly when tan−1x2+tan−115−x4=2π. For a,b>0,
Since 193≈13.89, both roots, x≈0.55 and x≈14.45, lie in (0,15). There are two points on the cushion at which the paths to A and B meet at a right angle.
(e) As x increases, x2 decreases; since tan−1 is increasing, ∠APM=tan−1x2 decreases. As x increases, 15−x decreases, so 15−x4 increases and ∠BPN=tan−115−x4 increases.
So the difference ∠APM−∠BPN strictly decreases as P moves from M to N. A strictly decreasing quantity can be zero at most once. It is zero at x=5, positive for x<5 and negative for x>5, so x=5 is the one and only bounce point.