Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 78 of 80
An architect's desk lamp has two straight arms joined at an elbow E .
Question 785 marksHard
An architect's desk lamp has two straight arms joined at an elbow E. The lower arm OE is 3 dm long and turns about a fixed pivot O; the upper arm EL is 5 dm long and carries the bulb L. To place the bulb at a distance OL=r dm from the pivot, the controller must set the elbow angle θ=∠OEL, with 0≤θ≤π. The cosine rule in triangle OEL gives
cosθ=2⋅3⋅532+52−r2=3034−r2
so the controller computes θ=cos−1(3034−r2). In the same way, the angle φ=∠EOL at the pivot satisfies cosφ=6r9+r2−25.
Attempt any four of the following five sub-questions.
(a) Find the elbow angle when the bulb is to be at r=7 dm, and when it is to be at r=19 dm.
(b) Find all distances r>0 for which the controller can compute θ, and describe the shape of the lamp at the two extreme distances.
(c) Find all reachable distances for which the elbow angle is obtuse, and all for which it is at least 65π.
(d) The bulb is to be placed at r=4 dm. Write the elbow angle as a value of tan−1 and also as a value of sin−1. Find φ, and hence write the third angle ∠OLE of the triangle as a value of tan−1.
(e) A technician reprograms the controller to work with tanθ. Show that for every reachable r with r=34,
tanθ=34−r2(r2−4)(64−r2)
The new program sets θ=tan−1(34−r2(r2−4)(64−r2)). Test it at r=7, explain what goes wrong, and give a correct formula for θ when 34<r<8.
(a) For r=7:
cosθ=3034−49=−21⇒θ=cos−1(−21)=π−3π=32π
For r=19:
cosθ=3034−19=21⇒θ=cos−121=3π
(b)cos−1 needs its input in [−1,1]:
−1≤3034−r2≤1⟺−30≤34−r2≤30⟺4≤r2≤64⟺2≤r≤8
At r=2: cosθ=1, so θ=0. The upper arm is folded back along the lower arm and the bulb is 5−3=2 dm from O.
At r=8: cosθ=−1, so θ=π. The two arms lie in one straight line and the bulb is 3+5=8 dm from O.
No other distance can be reached, which is exactly where the input of cos−1 leaves [−1,1].
(c) On [0,π] the cosine is decreasing, so θ is obtuse exactly when cosθ<0:
3034−r2<0⟺r2>34
With (b), the elbow is obtuse for 34<r≤8.
Since cos−1 is decreasing, θ≥65π exactly when cosθ≤cos65π=−23:
3034−r2≤−23⟺r2≥34+153
As 34+153≈59.98<64, this gives 34+153≤r≤8, about 7.74≤r≤8.
(d) For r=4, cosθ=3034−16=53. The angle is acute, with sinθ=1−259=54 and tanθ=34. All three principal values below lie in (0,2π), so
θ=cos−153=tan−134=sin−154
At the pivot,
cosφ=6⋅49+16−25=0⇒φ=cos−10=2π
so the lower arm is perpendicular to OL (indeed 32+42=52). The angles of the triangle add to π, so
because 302−(34−r2)2=(30−34+r2)(30+34−r2). Dividing by cosθ=3034−r2, which is non-zero when r=34, gives the stated formula for tanθ.
Test at r=7:
tanθ=34−4945⋅15=−15153=−3
and the program returns tan−1(−3)=−3π. A negative elbow angle is impossible, and (a) shows the true angle is 32π.
What goes wrong: tan−1 only returns values in (−2π,2π). For 34<r<8 the true θ is obtuse, so tanθ<0, and the principal value picks out θ−π, which has the same tangent. The correct formula there is
θ=π+tan−1(34−r2(r2−4)(64−r2))(34<r<8)
Check: at r=7 it gives π−3π=32π. For 2≤r<34 the elbow is acute and the technician's program is correct.