Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 2 of 80
Aniline, when heated with chloroform and ethanolic potassium hydroxide, gives a foul-smelling product.
Question 21 markMCQMedium
Aniline, when heated with chloroform and ethanolic potassium hydroxide, gives a foul-smelling product. Four changes to this experiment are proposed:
P: aniline is replaced by ethanamine
Q: chloroform is replaced by tetrachloromethane, CCl4
R: ethanolic KOH is replaced by ethanolic NaOH
S: aniline is replaced by N-methylaniline
Which of the changes would still give a foul-smelling product?
Select your answer
(A) P only
(B) P, R and S only
(C) Q and R only
(D) P and R only
Correct answer
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
The foul-smelling product is an isocyanide (carbylamine), and the reaction is the carbylamine reaction (isocyanide test). NCERT: aliphatic and aromatic primary amines, on heating with chloroform and ethanolic KOH, form isocyanides; secondary and tertiary amines do not.
C6H5NH2+CHCl3+3KOHheatC6H5NC+3KCl+3H2O
Look at where the atoms go. The carbon of −N≡C comes from CHCl3. Chloroform gives up its one H and all three Cl, the amine gives up both of its N–H hydrogens, and the three HCl formed are neutralised by 3 KOH.
P (ethanamine): still works. Ethanamine is a primary amine, so it gives ethyl isocyanide:
C2H5NH2+CHCl3+3KOHheatC2H5NC+3KCl+3H2O
Q (CCl4): does not work.CCl4 has no hydrogen. Its carbon would have to lose four chlorines, and it cannot supply the one-carbon unit that becomes the −NC carbon. No isocyanide forms.
R (ethanolic NaOH): still works. The alkali only removes the HCl formed. NaOH is as strong a base as KOH:
C6H5NH2+CHCl3+3NaOHheatC6H5NC+3NaCl+3H2O
S (N-methylaniline): does not work. N-Methylaniline, C6H5NHCH3, is a secondary amine with only one H on nitrogen. Forming R–N≡C needs nitrogen to lose two hydrogens, so secondary amines do not give the test.
Why the other options are wrong:
(A) misses R: changing the alkali from KOH to NaOH does not stop the reaction.
(B) includes S, but a secondary amine cannot form an isocyanide.
(C) includes Q, but CCl4 lacks the hydrogen that chloroform loses, and it leaves out P, although ethanamine is a primary amine.