Butanone, , reacts with HCN in the presence of a trace of base to give 2-hydroxy-2-methylbutanenitrile, . The product molecule is chiral, but the product obtained is optically inactive. Which statement explains this?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 74 of 80
Butanone, CH₃COCH₂CH₃ , reacts with HCN in the presence of a trace of base to give 2-hydroxy-2-methylbutanenitrile…
(A) The product carbon bearing –OH and –CN is not a stereocentre, because two of its groups are identical.
(B) attacks in the plane of the carbonyl group, so only one product with a plane of symmetry forms.
(C) The bulkier ethyl group blocks one face completely, so only one enantiomer forms, and a single enantiomer is optically inactive.
- Correct answer
(D) The carbonyl carbon is and planar, and attacks from above and from below the plane with equal probability, giving equal amounts of the two enantiomers (a racemic mixture).
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
Step 1 – Check that the product is chiral. The carbon bearing –OH carries four different groups: –OH, –CN, –CH and –CHCH. It is a stereocentre, so the product exists as a pair of enantiomers.
Step 2 – Look at how the nucleophile attacks. NCERT: the nucleophile attacks the carbonyl carbon from a direction approximately perpendicular to the plane of its orbitals. The carbonyl group and the three atoms attached to it lie in one plane, so there are two faces, above and below. Butanone has no stereocentre, so neither face is favoured: attack from above gives one enantiomer and attack from below gives its mirror image, in exactly equal amounts.


Step 3 – Result. A 50 : 50 mixture of enantiomers is a racemic mixture. The rotation of one enantiomer is cancelled by the equal and opposite rotation of the other, so the product is optically inactive although every molecule is chiral.
Why the other options are wrong:
- (A) No two groups on that carbon are identical (–CH and –CH differ), so it is a stereocentre.
- (B) Attack is perpendicular to the plane, not in it, and the product has no plane of symmetry.
- (C) Methyl and ethyl are too similar in size for one face to be blocked, and a single pure enantiomer would be optically active.
