(i) Benzoic acid and 2,4,6-trinitrophenol.
Rule: an acid releases CO2 from hydrogencarbonate only if it is stronger than carbonic acid, i.e. its pKa is below 6.35. Only benzoic acid (4.19) and 2,4,6-trinitrophenol (0.38) qualify. 4-Nitrophenol (7.1) is close but still weaker, so it does not effervesce, and phenol and ethanol are much weaker.

(ii)
K=[HA][HCO3−][A−][H2CO3]=[HA][A−][H+]×[H+][HCO3−][H2CO3]=Ka(H2CO3)Ka(HA)
logK=pKa(H2CO3)−pKa(HA)
Benzoic acid: K=106.35−4.19=102.16≈ 145. The equilibrium lies well to the right, so H2CO3 forms and decomposes to CO2: effervescence.
4-Nitrophenol: K=106.35−7.1=10−0.75≈ 0.18. The equilibrium lies to the left, so very little CO2 is released.
(iii) Only the sodium phenoxide solution turns turbid: phenol is set free.
Dissolved CO2 acts as the acid H2CO3 (pKa 6.35). An acid displaces a weaker acid from its salt, and the equilibrium constant is again logK=pKa(acid formed)−pKa(acid used):
C6H5ONa+CO2+H2O⟶C6H5OH+NaHCO3
K=1010.0−6.35=103.65≈4.5×103
Phenol (pKa 10.0) is weaker than carbonic acid, so the equilibrium lies far to the right; phenol, which is only sparingly soluble, separates and the solution turns milky.
C6H5COONa+CO2+H2O⇌C6H5COOH+NaHCO3K=104.19−6.35=10−2.16≈6.9×10−3
Benzoic acid (pKa 4.19) is stronger than carbonic acid, so the equilibrium lies to the left and no benzoic acid separates; the solution stays clear. This is exactly the reverse of part (i), where benzoic acid decomposes NaHCO3.

(iv) 2,4,6-Trinitrophenol (pKa 0.38) is a phenol, yet it is stronger than benzoic acid (pKa 4.19):
Ka(benzoic acid)Ka(picric acid)=104.19−0.38=103.81≈6.5×103
In the picrate ion the three –NO2 groups are at the two ortho and the para positions, exactly the ring carbons where phenoxide places its negative charge. Each –NO2 withdraws that charge by resonance (–R) and induction (–I) onto its own oxygen atoms. The charge is thus spread over up to seven oxygen atoms, which stabilises picrate far more than benzoate is stabilised by its two. So "carboxylic acids > phenols" holds for simple phenols, not for phenols carrying several strong electron-withdrawing groups.
