Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 70 of 80
Phenol is treated with concentrated H₂SO₄ under two different conditions.
Question 702 marksHard
Phenol is treated with concentrated H2SO4 under two different conditions.
At room temperature (about 298 K) the main product is 2-hydroxybenzenesulphonic acid.
At 373 K the main product is 4-hydroxybenzenesulphonic acid.
When the 2-hydroxy acid is itself heated with concentrated H2SO4 at 373 K, it changes into the 4-hydroxy acid.
(a) Write balanced equations for the two sulphonations and explain why only the ortho and para acids form. [1]
(b) Explain why the product changes from ortho to para as the temperature is raised, and what the third observation tells you about the reaction. [1]
(a) The –OH group releases electrons into the ring by resonance (+R), so the ortho and para carbons are electron rich and the ring is attacked there. The meta carbons receive no extra electron density, so no meta acid forms. The acid is written on the left as a reagent, and water is the by-product:
C6H5OH+H2SO4298Ko-HOC6H4SO3H+H2O
C6H5OH+H2SO4373Kp-HOC6H4SO3H+H2O
Atom check: C 6 = 6; H 6 + 2 = 8 = 6 + 2; O 1 + 4 = 5 = 4 + 1; S 1 = 1.
(b) Two different ideas decide the product.
At 298 K the product that forms faster wins. Attack at the ortho position is faster (it needs less energy to start, and there are two ortho positions against one para). At room temperature the reaction does not have enough energy to reverse, so whatever forms first stays. The ortho acid is the main product. This is called kinetic control.
At 373 K the more stable product wins. In the ortho acid the bulky –SO3H group sits right next to –OH and the two crowd each other. In the para acid they are far apart, so the para acid is more stable. At 373 K there is enough energy for sulphonation to run backwards as well as forwards: the –SO3H group keeps coming off and going back on. Over time the mixture collects the product that is hardest to reverse, the more stable para acid. This is called thermodynamic control.
The third observation proves that sulphonation is reversible. The ortho acid loses its –SO3H group (giving back phenol and H2SO4), and the phenol is sulphonated again, this time ending up at the para position:
o-HOC6H4SO3H+H2O⇌C6H5OH+H2SO4
o-HOC6H4SO3H373K,H2SO4p-HOC6H4SO3H
The overall change is only a move of the –SO3H group, so the formula C6H6O4S is the same on both sides. Low temperature gives the faster-formed ortho acid; high temperature gives the more stable para acid.