Four liquids are each shaken with an equal volume of water in a separating funnel and left to stand. The organic liquid is insoluble in water in every case. In which funnel does the organic liquid form the upper layer?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 4 of 80
Four liquids are each shaken with an equal volume of water in a separating funnel and left to stand.
Question 41 markMCQMedium
Select your answer
(A) dichloromethane,
(B) 1-iodopropane
(C) 1-bromopropane
- Correct answer
(D) 1-chloropropane
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
The liquid that is less dense than water () floats on top. NCERT states that bromo, iodo and polychloro derivatives are heavier than water, and that density increases with the number of halogen atoms and with the atomic mass of the halogen. A monochloro compound with a small alkyl group is the only one here that can be lighter than water.
NCERT Table 6.3 gives:
| Liquid | Density / g mL | Compared with water |
|---|---|---|
| 1-chloropropane | 0.89 | lighter, so it floats |
| 1-bromopropane | 1.335 | heavier, so it sinks |
| dichloromethane | 1.336 | heavier, so it sinks |
| 1-iodopropane | 1.747 | heavier, so it sinks |

Why the other options are wrong:
- (A) is the trap. Dichloromethane is a chloro compound, but it has two Cl atoms on one carbon, which makes it a polychloro compound, and it is denser than water.
- (B) and (C) Br and I are much heavier atoms than Cl, so these compounds are denser than water and form the lower layer.
