Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
What decides optical purity. All three alcohols are chiral: octan-2-ol, 1-phenylethanol and 3-methylhexan-3-ol each have a carbon bearing four different groups. The optical purity of the product therefore depends only on the mechanism:
- SN2: back-side attack, complete inversion, optical purity kept.
- SN1: planar carbocation attacked from both faces, racemisation, optical purity lost.
The reagent is the same for all three, so the result depends on how easily each halide ionises.
I, 2-bromooctane. A simple secondary halide. Its carbocation is only secondary, with no resonance stabilisation, so ionisation is slow and the strong nucleophile OH− at high concentration wins by SN2. This is NCERT's example: (–)-2-bromooctane gives (+)-octan-2-ol with inversion. The product is almost optically pure.
II, 1-bromo-1-phenylethane. Also secondary, but benzylic. It ionises readily to C6H5C+HCH3, whose charge is spread into the ring by resonance. A large share of the reaction goes through this planar ion, so much of the 1-phenylethanol is racemic and its optical purity is lower.
III, 3-bromo-3-methylhexane. Tertiary: SN2 is blocked and the halide reacts through the stable tertiary carbocation, so the 3-methylhexan-3-ol is essentially racemic (much alkene also forms). Its optical purity is the lowest.

Order of optical purity of the alcohol: I > II > III.
Why the others are wrong:
- (A) A stable carbocation makes the reaction fast, but a planar carbocation is attacked equally from both faces, so III gives the least optically pure product. Speed is not stereochemical control.
- (C) The phenyl group does not hold the configuration; it stabilises the planar benzylic carbocation, which is exactly what lets the configuration be lost.
- (D) An optically pure reactant keeps its purity only through a stereospecific (SN2) path. Having one stereocentre in the product says nothing about how much of each enantiomer is formed.