Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 69 of 80
A student plans to make the nitrile (CH₃)₃C–CN by heating 2-bromo-2-methylpropane with sodium cyanide in aqueous…
Question 692 marksMedium
A student plans to make the nitrile (CH3)3C–CN by heating 2-bromo-2-methylpropane with sodium cyanide in aqueous ethanol. Almost no nitrile is obtained; the main organic product is a gas that decolourises bromine water.
(a) Identify the gas, write a balanced equation for its formation, and explain why the cyanide ion reacts in this way with this halide, so that the tertiary nitrile cannot be made by this method. [1]
(b) The isomeric bromide 1-bromo-2-methylpropane, (CH3)2CHCH2Br, heated with NaCN under the same conditions gives a nitrile in good yield. Name this nitrile and explain the difference in behaviour. [1]
Both halides have the formula C4H9Br and meet the same reagent, so the difference must come from the structure of the halide. NCERT: substitution and elimination compete; a primary alkyl halide prefers SN2, while a tertiary halide undergoes SN1 or elimination.
(a) The gas is 2-methylpropene, (CH3)2C=CH2 (an alkene, so it decolourises bromine water):
SN2 is impossible. The carbon carrying Br holds three methyl groups, which block back-side attack by CN−; tertiary halides are the least reactive in SN2.
CN− is also a base. It is the anion of the weak acid HCN, so it can remove a proton. The halide has nine β-hydrogens on the outside of the molecule, where CN− can reach them without approaching the crowded carbon. Removing a β-hydrogen as Br leaves is the easiest route, so elimination wins and the cyanide ends up as HCN.
Even the part that ionises to the tertiary carbocation mostly loses H+ to give the same alkene (or is captured by the solvent), so very little (CH3)3C–CN (2,2-dimethylpropanenitrile) forms.
So a nitrile with CN on a tertiary carbon cannot be prepared from a tertiary halide and cyanide.
(b) The product is 3-methylbutanenitrile, (CH3)2CHCH2CN (the nitrile carbon is C-1 of a four-carbon chain and the methyl group is on C-3; CN adds one carbon to the halide):
Here Br is on a primary carbon carrying two small hydrogen atoms, so CN− can reach the back of the C–Br carbon and substitution by SN2 is fast. There is only one β-hydrogen, and the primary halide prefers SN2, so substitution beats elimination. The same reagent acts as a nucleophile towards the primary halide and as a base towards the tertiary one.