Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 27 of 80
Read the passage and answer the questions that follow.
Question 274 marksMedium
Read the passage and answer the questions that follow.
The –OH group of an alcohol can be replaced by a halogen using concentrated halogen acids, phosphorus halides or thionyl chloride. A chemist has 2-methylpropan-2-ol, butan-1-ol, butan-2-ol and phenol. When 2-methylpropan-2-ol is simply shaken with concentrated HCl at room temperature, an oily layer of 2-chloro-2-methylpropane separates within minutes. Butan-1-ol shows no change under the same conditions; it is converted into 1-chlorobutane only when it is heated with concentrated HCl in the presence of anhydrous ZnCl2.
(i) In both alcohols the C–O bond breaks after the –OH group is protonated. Explain, in terms of the intermediate formed, why the tertiary alcohol reacts so much more readily than butan-1-ol. [1]
(ii) Arrange the three butanols (2-methylpropan-2-ol, butan-1-ol and butan-2-ol) in decreasing order of reactivity towards concentrated HCl, and predict whether butan-2-ol would react on simple shaking at room temperature. Give a reason. [1]
(iii) Why cannot chlorobenzene be prepared by treating phenol with HCl in the same way?
(A) Phenol is a gas. (B) The C–O bond in phenol has partial double bond character and is too strong to break. (C) Phenol has no lone pair on oxygen. (D) Chlorobenzene reacts with HCl as soon as it forms. [1]
(iv) The 2-chloro-2-methylpropane formed from 2-methylpropan-2-ol is warmed with aqueous NaOH. State the mechanism of this hydrolysis and write its rate law. [1]
(i) After protonation, the C–O bond breaks and water leaves, leaving a carbocation. The easier this carbocation is to form, the faster the alcohol reacts.
(CH3)3C–OH+H+⇌(CH3)3C–O+H2→(CH3)3C++H2O
(CH3)3C++Cl−→(CH3)3C–Cl
2-Methylpropan-2-ol gives the tertiary carbocation (CH3)3C+. Its positive carbon carries three alkyl groups, which push electrons towards it (+I effect), and nine C–H bonds next to it spread the charge by hyperconjugation. This ion is quite stable, so it forms easily and the reaction goes on simple shaking.
Butan-1-ol would have to give the primary carbocation CH3CH2CH2CH2+, with only one alkyl group and two neighbouring C–H bonds to stabilise it. It is far too unstable to form under these conditions, so the C–O bond breaks only with the help of the anhydrous ZnCl2 catalyst and heat.
Butan-2-ol would give a secondary carbocation, CH3C+HCH2CH3, stabilised by two alkyl groups. This is more stable than the primary ion but much less stable than the tertiary one. So butan-2-ol reacts faster than butan-1-ol, but it would not react on simple shaking at room temperature; like a primary alcohol, it needs anhydrous ZnCl2 as a catalyst:
(iii) — (B). In phenol, a lone pair on oxygen is in conjugation with the ring, which gives the C–O bond partial double bond character. The bond is stronger than a single bond and difficult to break, so the methods used for alcohols do not work for making aryl halides. Phenol is a solid, not a gas (A). Its oxygen does have lone pairs; that is exactly why conjugation occurs (C). Chlorobenzene is unreactive towards HCl (D).
(iv) 2-Chloro-2-methylpropane is a 3∘ halide. The carbon is too crowded for backside attack, but it ionises easily to the stable 3∘ carbocation, so hydrolysis follows the SN1 mechanism: