Chlorobenzene and bromobenzene are made by treating benzene with or in the presence of iron or iron(III) chloride. A student wants to make fluorobenzene and iodobenzene in the same way. Which statement correctly explains what happens?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 23 of 80
Chlorobenzene and bromobenzene are made by treating benzene with Cl₂ or Br₂ in the presence of iron or iron(III)…
- Correct answer
(A) Fluorination is too vigorous to control. Iodination is reversible, so an oxidising agent such as or must be added to remove the HI formed.
(B) Fluorination is reversible and needs an oxidising agent to remove HF, while iodination is too vigorous to control.
(C) Both work exactly like chlorination and bromination. Only the yields are somewhat lower.
(D) Iodine is too unreactive to substitute at all, whereas fluorine gives pure fluorobenzene without any catalyst.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:
NCERT gives two separate limits of direct halogenation.
Fluorine is too reactive. Fluorine reacts too violently with the organic compound for a controlled monosubstitution, so fluoro compounds are not prepared by this method.
Iodination is reversible. The HI formed is a reducing agent and pushes the reaction back:
An oxidising agent such as or is added to oxidise HI (back to ) as it forms. This removes a product, so by Le Chatelier's principle the equilibrium shifts to the right.
Why the other options are wrong:
- (B) swaps the two problems. It is iodination that is reversible, and fluorination that is uncontrollable.
- (C) ignores both limits.
- (D) Iodination does occur once an oxidising agent is present. Direct fluorination is not a clean route at all.
