Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 61 of 80
An optically active sample of 2-iodooctane is dissolved in dry acetone containing sodium iodide in which some of the…
Question 612 marksHard
An optically active sample of 2-iodooctane is dissolved in dry acetone containing sodium iodide in which some of the iodide ions are radioactive (I∗−). No new compound is formed, yet the optical rotation of the solution slowly falls to zero.
At the start of the experiment, measured in the same units (mol of 2-iodooctane per litre per second), the rate at which optical activity is lost is found to be exactly twice the rate at which radioactive iodine enters the organic compound.
(a) Why does the solution lose its optical activity although the only organic compound present at the end is still 2-iodooctane? [1]
(b) What does the factor of exactly 2 prove about the stereochemistry of each substitution event? [1]
(a) Iodide ion is a good nucleophile and also a good leaving group, so I∗− displaces the iodine of the secondary halide by SN2 in acetone:
I∗−+C6H13CHICH3dry acetoneC6H13CHI∗CH3+I−
The nucleophile enters from the side opposite the leaving iodine, so the configuration at C-2 is inverted. The "product" is 2-iodooctane again, but with the mirror-image configuration, i.e. the other enantiomer. As exchanges continue (ordinary and radioactive iodide both keep attacking), molecules keep switching between the two configurations until the two enantiomers are present in equal amounts. The solution then contains a racemic mixture, whose rotation is zero.
(b) Rotation is proportional to the excess of one enantiomer over the other. Suppose the sample contains a molecules of the original enantiomer and b of the other, so the excess is (a−b).
If one exchange inverts, a falls by 1 and b rises by 1, so the excess falls by 2.
If it gave retention, the excess would not change at all.
If it gave racemisation (equal attack from both faces), the excess would fall by only 1 on average.
Early in the experiment almost every exchange converts an original molecule, so an optical loss of exactly 2× the exchange rate means every single substitution event occurs with inversion of configuration. This is the experimental proof that an SN2 reaction (Hughes and Ingold's mechanism, NCERT) always proceeds by back-side attack with Walden inversion.