Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 55 of 80
A compound X, C₇H₇Cl , contains a benzene ring.
Question 551 markMCQHard
A compound X, C7H7Cl, contains a benzene ring. Its chlorine is not replaced even on prolonged boiling with aqueous NaOH. When X is treated with chloromethane and sodium in dry ether, it gives the hydrocarbon Y, C8H10. On ring nitration, Y gives three different mononitro products.
What is X?
Select your answer
(A) 1-Chloro-3-methylbenzene
Correct answer
(B) 1-Chloro-4-methylbenzene
(C) (Chloromethyl)benzene
(D) 1-Chloro-2-methylbenzene
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation:
Clue 1 — aryl halide. A chlorine that survives boiling aqueous NaOH must be on the ring (aryl C–Cl: partial double-bond character, sp2 carbon). This rules out (C), benzyl chloride, whose benzylic Cl is hydrolysed readily. So X is one of the three chlorotoluenes.
Clue 2 — Wurtz–Fittig. Sodium joins the aryl group to a methyl group, so the ring Cl is replaced by CH3:
Y is a dimethylbenzene (xylene), and the two methyl groups keep the same relative positions as Cl and CH3 had in X.
Clue 3 — count the kinds of ring hydrogen. Each different kind of ring H gives a different mononitro product:
o-xylene: 2 kinds → 2 products
m-xylene: 3 kinds (between the methyls; next to one methyl; opposite both) → 3 products
p-xylene: all four H equivalent → 1 product
So Y is m-xylene and X is 1-chloro-3-methylbenzene.
Why the others are wrong:
(B) gives p-xylene, with only one mononitro product.
(C) is the trap. Benzyl chloride with CH3Cl/Na would give ethylbenzene, which also gives three mononitro products (o, m, p). But clue 1 excludes it, because benzylic Cl is readily replaced by aqueous NaOH.