Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 53 of 80
P is an optically active compound of formula C₉H₁1 Br that contains one benzene ring.
Question 532 marksHard
P is an optically active compound of formula C9H11Br that contains one benzene ring.
With sodium in dry ether, P gives a hydrocarbon of formula C18H22.
With alcoholic KOH, P gives a single alkene Q, C9H10 (no structural isomer of Q is formed). Q adds H2 over Ni to give propylbenzene, C6H5CH2CH2CH3.
With aqueous KOH, P is hydrolysed quickly to an alcohol R. Each molecule of R is chiral, yet the product R shows no optical rotation.
(a) Deduce the structure and IUPAC name of P. Show why the other optically active bromide with the propylbenzene skeleton does not fit, and write balanced equations for the reactions of P with Na, with alcoholic KOH and with aqueous KOH. [1]
(b) Explain why R is optically inactive although P was optically active. [1]
(a) Identifying P
Skeleton. Q gives propylbenzene on hydrogenation, and forming Q from P changes only the C–Br region, so P has the propylbenzene skeleton, C6H5–C–C–C, with Br on one side-chain carbon. A bromine on the ring is ruled out because an aryl halide cannot lose HBr with alcoholic KOH.
Chirality. Br can sit on C1, C2 or C3 of the side chain:
C6H5CH2CH2CH2Br (Br on C3) has no carbon with four different groups, so it is achiral and cannot be P.
C6H5CHBrCH2CH3 (Br on C1) and C6H5CH2CHBrCH3 (Br on C2) are both chiral.
The single alkene decides. In 2-bromo-1-phenylpropane the C–Br carbon has β-hydrogens on both sides (C1 and C3), so alcoholic KOH gives two alkenes: 1-phenylprop-1-ene (major, Saytzeff) and 3-phenylprop-1-ene (minor). In 1-bromo-1-phenylpropane the only β-carbon with hydrogen is C2, because the other neighbour of the C–Br carbon is a ring carbon. Only one alkene can form.
P = 1-bromo-1-phenylpropane, C6H5CHBrCH2CH3, a secondary benzylic bromide.
Equations
Wurtz reaction (two P units join at the old C–Br carbons):
R is 1-phenylpropan-1-ol. Its C1 carries H, OH, C2H5 and C6H5, so it is chiral.
(b) Why R is racemic
P is a secondary benzylic halide, and it is hydrolysed in water, a polar protic solvent. It reacts by the SN1 mechanism:
Slow step: the C–Br bond ionises to give C6H5C+HCH2CH3. This carbocation is stabilised by resonance: the positive charge spreads to the ortho and para carbons of the ring. That is why P is hydrolysed quickly.
The carbocation carbon is sp2 hybridised and planar, so the original configuration of P is lost.
Fast step:OH− attacks the planar carbon from either face with equal probability. Attack from the face the Br left gives the alcohol with the same configuration (retention). Attack from the opposite face gives the inverted configuration.
The two products are enantiomers formed in equal amounts, so R is a racemic (±) mixture. The rotation of the d-form is cancelled by the equal and opposite rotation of the l-form. This is racemisation, and the net optical rotation is zero.