Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 51 of 80
Read the passage and answer the questions that follow.
Question 514 marksHard
Read the passage and answer the questions that follow.
A, B and C are three isomers of formula C8H9Br. Each contains one benzene ring.
A is optically active and is hydrolysed faster than B or C in warm aqueous ethanol.
B is optically inactive. It is hydrolysed more slowly than A.
When heated with alcoholic KOH, A and B both give the same hydrocarbon D, C8H8.
C is not affected by boiling aqueous NaOH or by alcoholic KOH. The two groups on its ring are para to each other.
The Grignard reagents of A, B and C, on treatment with water, all give the same hydrocarbon E, C8H10.
(i) Identify E and D. [1]
(ii) Identify A and B. Classify the C–Br carbon in each, and show why a methylbenzyl bromide such as CH3C6H4CH2Br cannot be B. [1]
(iii) Identify C and give two reasons why its bromine is not replaced by boiling aqueous NaOH. [1]
(iv) Arrange A, B and C in decreasing order of SN1 reactivity. Explain why A reacts faster than B. [1]
(i) E and D
A Grignard reagent with water replaces –MgBr by –H, so all three bromides share the carbon skeleton of E. A C8H10 hydrocarbon with one benzene ring is either ethylbenzene or a dimethylbenzene (xylene). A is chiral, so its C–Br carbon must carry four different groups. H, Br, CH3 and C6H5 on one side-chain carbon is possible only on an ethyl side chain; on a xylene skeleton the Br would sit on a CH2 or on the ring, and neither is chiral.
E = ethylbenzene, C6H5CH2CH3.
D, C8H8, is formed from A and B by loss of HBr, so it has a C=C in the side chain: D = ethenylbenzene (styrene), C6H5CH=CH2.
(ii) A and B
Br can sit in only two side-chain positions on an ethylbenzene skeleton:
A = (1-bromoethyl)benzene, C6H5CHBrCH3. The C–Br carbon is secondary and benzylic. It carries H, Br, CH3 and C6H5, so it is chiral, which explains the optical activity.
B = (2-bromoethyl)benzene, C6H5CH2CH2Br. The C–Br carbon is primary, and it is not benzylic because it is one carbon away from the ring. No carbon has four different groups, so B is achiral.
Both lose HBr towards the same carbon–carbon bond and give D:
A methylbenzyl bromide, CH3C6H4CH2Br, is also an achiral C8H9Br, but it fails two clues. Its β-carbon is a ring carbon with no H, so it cannot give an alkene with alcoholic KOH. Its Grignard reagent with water gives a xylene, not ethylbenzene.
(iii) C = 1-bromo-4-ethylbenzene, Br–C6H4–C2H5 (para). It is an aryl halide, and its Grignard reagent with water gives ethylbenzene. Its Br resists substitution because:
Resonance: a lone pair on Br is delocalised into the ring, which gives the C–Br bond partial double-bond character. The bond is harder to break.
sp2 carbon: the ring carbon has more s-character, holds the bonding pair more tightly, and forms a shorter, stronger C–Br bond. A phenyl cation is not stabilised by resonance, so the SN1 route is ruled out, and the electron-rich ring repels the incoming OH−.
Alcoholic KOH cannot remove HBr either: the C–Br carbon and its neighbours are sp2 carbons that are already part of the aromatic ring, so no new C=C can form there.
(iv) SN1 order: A > B > C
A ionises to C6H5C+HCH3, a secondary benzylic carbocation. The positive charge is delocalised into the ring by resonance, and the methyl group also releases electrons.
B would have to form C6H5CH2C+H2, a primary carbocation. The ring is not attached to the positive carbon, so there is no resonance stabilisation.