Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
Each statement has to be judged by the factor that actually controls the mechanism: carbocation stability for SN1, crowding at the α-carbon for SN2, and leaving-group ability for both.
| No. | Verdict | Deciding factor |
|---|
| 1 | Correct | Both are 1°, but the benzyl cation C6H5C+H2 is stabilised by resonance with the ring; the propyl cation is not. |
| 2 | Wrong | In a vinylic halide the C–Br bond has partial double-bond character (resonance) and the carbon is sp2; a vinylic cation is very unstable. Bromoethene does not undergo SN1 at all. |
| 3 | Wrong | Three methyl groups crowd the back side of the α-carbon; SN2 order is 1° > 2° > 3°. |
| 4 | Correct | NCERT: for a given alkyl group, R–I > R–Br > R–Cl >> R–F in both mechanisms, because the weakest, longest C–X bond breaks most easily. |
| 5 | Wrong | Both are 1°, but the (CH3)2CH– group releases more electrons (+I) than CH3CH2CH2–, so its carbocation is more stable. NCERT (Example 6.7) places (CH3)2CHCH2Br above 1-bromobutane in SN1. |
| 6 | Correct | Bromobenzene does not undergo SN2 under ordinary conditions (sp2 carbon, partial double bond, electron-rich ring repels the nucleophile), while benzyl bromide reacts readily. |
Correct statements: 1, 4 and 6, so three.
Why the distractors tempt:
- (A) Two — forgetting that statement 4 applies to SN1 as well as SN2.
- (C) Four — accepting statement 5 by reasoning "both are primary, and branching always slows things down". Branching near the reaction centre slows SN2, but in SN1 the extra +I effect speeds up ionisation.
- (D) Five — also accepting statement 2, i.e. treating a vinylic halide like an allylic one.