Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 67 of 80
Read the passage and answer the questions that follow.
Question 674 marksMedium
Read the passage and answer the questions that follow.
NCERT lists the light absorbed by four octahedral cobalt(III) complexes. Each complex shows one broad d–d absorption band:
Complex
Band maximum / nm
Colour of the complex
[CoCl(NH3)5]2+
535
violet
[Co(NH3)5(H2O)]3+
500
red
[Co(NH3)6]3+
475
yellow-orange
[Co(CN)6]3−
310 (not in the visible region)
pale yellow
Take the energy at the band maximum as Δo. All four complexes are diamagnetic. (Given: NAhc=0.1196J m mol−1; visible light is about 400–750 nm.)
(i)Δo for [Co(NH3)6]3+ and for [Co(CN)6]3−, in kJ mol−1, are respectively: (A) 385.8 and 251.8 (B) 25.18 and 38.58 (C) 251.8 and 385.8 (D) 2.518×105 and 3.858×105[1]
(ii) Using only the data in the table, arrange Cl−, H2O, NH3 and CN− in order of increasing field strength. Explain why the first three complexes allow a fair comparison, and check your order against the spectrochemical series. [1]
(iii)[Co(CN)6]3− absorbs most strongly in the ultraviolet, yet it is pale yellow, not colourless. Explain. [1]
(iv) Why are all four complexes diamagnetic? (A) All four ligands, Cl−, H2O, NH3 and CN−, are strong-field ligands, so each of them forces the d electrons to pair (B) Every ion contains Co3+ (3d6) with at least five NH3 or six CN− ligands, so Δo exceeds the pairing energy; the electrons pair as t2g6eg0, leaving two 3d orbitals empty for d2sp3 hybridisation (C) A d6 ion always has all its electrons paired in an octahedral field, whatever the ligand (D) A complex can absorb visible light by a d–d transition only if all its d electrons are paired [1]
(i) — (C).
The energy absorbed per mole is Δo=NAhc/λ:
[Co(NH3)6]3+:Δo=475×10−9m0.1196J m mol−1=2.518×105J mol−1=251.8kJmol−1
[Co(CN)6]3−:Δo=310×10−9m0.1196J m mol−1=3.858×105J mol−1=385.8kJmol−1
The cyanido complex has the larger splitting, by a factor of 475/310=1.53.
(A) swaps the two values, as if Δo grew with λ; energy is inversely proportional to wavelength.
(B) converts nm to m with 10−8 instead of 10−9.
(D) gives the values in J mol⁻¹ but labels them kJ mol⁻¹.
(ii) The same equation gives Δo for the other two complexes:
A fair comparison. The first three complexes contain the same Co3+ ion and the same five NH3 ligands; only the sixth ligand differs (Cl−, H2O, NH3). Any change in Δo is therefore caused by that one ligand:
Δo:223.6(Cl−)<239.2(H2O)<251.8(NH3)
Replacing all six NH3 by CN− raises Δo further, to 385.8 kJ mol⁻¹, so CN− is the strongest of the four. The order of increasing field strength is:
Cl−<H2O<NH3<CN−
This agrees with the spectrochemical series, …Cl−<S2−<F−<OH−<C2O42−<H2O<NCS−<edta4−<NH3<en<CN−<CO. Note that the anion Cl− is the weakest and the neutral molecules lie above it, so field strength does not follow ligand charge.
(iii) A d–d absorption is a broad band, not a sharp line. For [Co(CN)6]3−, the very large Δo (385.8 kJ mol⁻¹) puts the band maximum at 310 nm, in the ultraviolet. The long-wavelength edge of the broad band still reaches the violet end of the visible range (about 400 nm), so a small amount of violet light is absorbed. The colour seen is the complementary colour of the absorbed light, which is yellow; because only the weak edge of the band absorbs, the colour is pale yellow. A complex whose band lay wholly in the ultraviolet would be colourless.
(iv) — (B).
Oxidation state and d count. In each ion, the charge balance gives cobalt +3: x−1=+2 for [CoCl(NH3)5]2+; x=+3 for the two ammine ions (neutral ligands); x−6=−3 for [Co(CN)6]3−. Co is [Ar]3d74s2, so Co3+ is 3d6.
Pairing. Five or six of the ligands in every ion are NH3 or CN−, strong-field ligands, and Δo is large in all four (223.6 to 385.8 kJ mol⁻¹). Δo exceeds the pairing energy P, so all six electrons enter the t2g level:
t2g6eg0:n=0,μ=0(0+2)=0BM(diamagnetic)
In VBT terms, the six electrons pair in three 3d orbitals, two 3d orbitals are empty, and with 4s and three 4p orbitals they give d2sp3 (inner orbital, octahedral) hybridisation.
(A) Cl− and H2O are weak-field ligands (low in the series). The chlorido and aqua complexes are low spin because the other five ligands are NH3.
(C) A d6 ion is not always paired: with the weak-field ligand F−, [CoF6]3− is high spin, t2g4eg2, with four unpaired electrons (4.90 BM).
(D) A d–d transition needs only an electron that can be promoted into an empty or half-filled higher level; [Ti(H2O)6]3+ (t2g1) is paramagnetic and still violet.