Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 66 of 80
For the cobalt(III) ion, take the pairing energy P = 21 ,000 cm^ -1 .
Question 663 marksHard
For the cobalt(III) ion, take the pairing energy P=21000cm−1. The crystal field splittings are:
Complex
Δo / cm⁻¹
[CoF6]3−
13 000
[Co(NH3)6]3+
23 000
Take the energy of an arrangement as its CFSE (from −0.4Δo per t2g electron and +0.6Δo per eg electron) plus P for every pair of electrons.
(a) Write the energy of the high-spin and the low-spin d6 arrangement in terms of Δo and P, and show that low spin is favoured only when Δo>P.
(b) Decide the spin state of each complex and find by how many cm⁻¹ the favoured arrangement is lower.
(c) Give the number of unpaired electrons, the spin-only magnetic moment and the VBT hybridisation (inner or outer orbital) of each complex.
(a) The two d6 arrangements
Co3+ is 3d6.
High spin, t2g4eg2 (one pair):
EHS=4(−0.4Δo)+2(0.6Δo)+P=−0.4Δo+P
Low spin, t2g6eg0 (three pairs):
ELS=6(−0.4Δo)+3P=−2.4Δo+3P
The difference is:
ELS−EHS=−2.0Δo+2P=2(P−Δo)
This is negative (low spin lower in energy) only when Δo>P.
(b) Spin states
[CoF6]3−:
ELS−EHS=2(21000−13000)=+16000cm−1
High spin is lower by 16 000 cm⁻¹, so [CoF6]3− is high spin.
[Co(NH3)6]3+:
ELS−EHS=2(21000−23000)=−4000cm−1
Low spin is lower by 4000 cm⁻¹, so [Co(NH3)6]3+ is low spin.
The larger CFSE of the low-spin arrangement (−2.4Δo against −0.4Δo) does not settle the matter by itself. It has to pay for two extra electron pairs, and for F− that cost is too high.
(c) Magnetism and bonding
Complex
Configuration
n
μ (BM)
Hybridisation
[CoF6]3−
t2g4eg2
4
24=4.90
sp3d2, outer orbital
[Co(NH3)6]3+
t2g6eg0
0
0 (diamagnetic)
d2sp3, inner orbital
In [CoF6]3− the 3d electrons stay unpaired, so the complex must use the outer 4d orbitals: sp3d2. In [Co(NH3)6]3+ the six 3d electrons pair up in three orbitals, which frees two inner 3d orbitals: d2sp3.