Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 62 of 80
Nickel and palladium are in the same group, and both Ni²+ and Pd²+ form [MCl₄]²- ions.
Question 621 markMCQHard
Nickel and palladium are in the same group, and both Ni2+ and Pd2+ form [MCl4]2− ions. Their measured magnetic moments are:
Complex
Magnetic moment / BM
[NiCl4]2−
2.83
[PdCl4]2−
0
[NiCl4]2− is tetrahedral and [PdCl4]2− is square planar, although Cl− is a weak-field ligand in both. Which statement correctly explains the difference?
Select your answer
(A) Pd2+ carries a higher charge than Ni2+, which makes Cl− behave as a strong-field ligand towards palladium
(B) The 4d orbitals of Pd2+ extend further towards the ligands than the 3d orbitals of Ni2+, so the splitting is much larger; even with Cl− it exceeds the pairing energy, the eight 4d electrons pair in four orbitals, and the empty 4d orbital gives dsp2 hybridisation
Correct answer
(C) Pd2+ has only six d electrons, so it needs no pairing to leave a d orbital empty for dsp2 hybridisation
(D) Pd2+ is a larger ion than Ni2+, so four Cl− ions can fit around it only if they lie in one plane
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation:
Step 1 — Electron counts. Ni is [Ar]3d84s2, so Ni2+ is 3d8. Pd is [Kr]4d10, so Pd2+ is 4d8. Both ions are d8 and both carry the same charge, +2.
Step 2 — Read the magnetic data.
μ=n(n+2)BM:2.83=2×4⇒n=2;0⇒n=0
[NiCl4]2− keeps two unpaired electrons; in [PdCl4]2− all eight d electrons are paired.
Step 3 — Nickel.Cl− is near the weak end of the spectrochemical series, and the splitting it produces with the compact 3d orbitals is smaller than the pairing energy. The 3d electrons are not forced to pair, no 3d orbital is freed, and the 4s and three 4p orbitals give sp3 hybrids: a tetrahedral ion, e4t24, with two unpaired electrons (2.83 BM).
Step 4 — Palladium. The 4d orbitals are larger and reach further towards the ligands, so for the same ligand and the same charge the crystal field splitting is much larger for a 4d ion than for a 3d ion. Even with Cl− it is larger than the pairing energy. The eight 4d electrons therefore pair in four 4d orbitals and leave one 4d orbital empty. This orbital, the 5s and two 5p orbitals form four dsp2 hybrids that take the four Cl− pairs:
The result is a square planar, diamagnetic ion (μ=0), as observed. The ligand did not change; the metal's d orbitals did.
Why the other options are wrong:
(A) Both metals are in the +2 state, so there is no difference in charge. The position of Cl− in the spectrochemical series does not change either; the larger splitting comes from the 4d orbitals.
(C)Pd2+ is 4d8, not d6 (Pd is 4d10 and loses two electrons). It needs pairing just as Ni2+ would.
(D) A larger central ion leaves more room around it, so size cannot force the ligands into a plane; a tetrahedron is in fact the less crowded arrangement (109.5° against 90°). The diamagnetism shows that the reason is electronic.