Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 61 of 80
For a cobalt(III) ion with a certain neutral ligand L, the octahedral complex [CoL₆]³+ has Δo = 23 ,000 cm^ -1 .
Question 611 markMCQMedium
For a cobalt(III) ion with a certain neutral ligand L, the octahedral complex [CoL6]3+ has Δo=23000cm−1. The pairing energy is P=19000cm−1.
Suppose a tetrahedral complex [CoL4]3+ could be made with the same metal ion, the same ligand and the same metal–ligand distance. What are the numbers of unpaired electrons in the octahedral and the tetrahedral complex?
Select your answer
(A) Octahedral 0; tetrahedral 0, because the same strong-field ligand forces pairing in both geometries
(B) Octahedral 4; tetrahedral 4, because both splittings are smaller than P
(C) Octahedral 0; tetrahedral 2, with the configuration e4t22
(D) Octahedral 0; tetrahedral 4, with the configuration e3t23
Correct answer
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
Co3+ is 3d6 (Co is 3d74s2; remove the two 4s electrons and one 3d electron).
Octahedral complex.Δo=23000cm−1 is greater than P=19000cm−1, so pairing in t2g costs less than promotion to eg. All six electrons go into t2g:
t2g6eg0⇒n=0(diamagnetic)
Tetrahedral complex. For the same metal, ligands and distance, NCERT gives Δt=94Δo:
Δt=94×23000=10222cm−1
Now Δt<P, so electrons spread out before pairing. In a tetrahedral field the lower set is e (two orbitals) and the upper set is t2 (three orbitals). Five electrons go in singly (e2t23) and the sixth pairs in the lower e set:
e3t23⇒n=4,μ=4(4+2)=24=4.90BM
This is why tetrahedral complexes are almost always high spin: the 94 factor makes Δt too small to beat the pairing energy even when the same ligands give a low-spin octahedral complex.
Why the other options are wrong:
(A) The ligand is the same, but the splitting is not. Comparing Δo (not Δt) with P for the tetrahedral case is the trap.
(B) Δo=23000cm−1 exceeds P, so the octahedral complex is low spin with no unpaired electrons.
(C) e4t22 is the low-spin tetrahedral arrangement. It would need Δt>P, but 10222<19000.