(a) Which oxidant attacks chloride
KMnO4: Ecell∘=1.52−1.36=+0.16 V(spontaneous)
K2Cr2O7: Ecell∘=1.33−1.36=−0.03 V(not spontaneous)
Permanganate oxidises chloride to chlorine:
2MnO4−+10Cl−+16H+→2Mn2++5Cl2+8H2O
Check: Mn 2, Cl 10, O 8, H 16 on each side; charge −2−10+16=+4 and +4. Electrons: 2×5=10 gained, 10×1=10 lost.
In an Fe2+ titration, part of the KMnO4 is used up oxidising Cl−, so more titrant is needed. The titre is too high and the iron content is overestimated. This is why NCERT calls permanganate titrations in HCl unsatisfactory.
(b) Where dichromate starts to attack chloride
Nernst equation for each couple:
ECr=1.33−60.059logc141=1.33+0.1377logc
ECl=1.36−20.059logc2=1.36−0.059logc
Dichromate oxidises chloride once ECr>ECl:
0.1377logc+0.059logc>1.36−1.33
logc>0.19670.03=0.153⇒c>1.4 M
In dilute HCl (below about 1.4 M), dichromate's potential stays below that of chlorine, so chloride is safe and the titre is correct. In concentrated HCl the fourteenth-power dependence on [H+] raises dichromate's potential above the chlorine couple, and chlorine is released. The margin is small, so dichromate titrations are always done in dilute acid.
