Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 73 of 80
A yellow solution of ammonium vanadate in dilute sulphuric acid is shaken with excess zinc amalgam.
Question 735 marksHard
A yellow solution of ammonium vanadate in dilute sulphuric acid is shaken with excess zinc amalgam. The colour changes in stages, yellow → blue → green → violet, and then stays violet. A sample is taken at each stage, and the spin-only magnetic moment of the vanadium species is measured:
(a) Deduce the oxidation state of vanadium at each stage from the magnetic data, and identify the species P, Q, R and S.
(b) Use the E∘ values to explain why the reduction stops at the violet stage and zinc never produces vanadium metal.
(c) Write the balanced ionic equation for the overall change from P to S.
(d) When the violet solution is kept in dilute acid under nitrogen (no air), bubbles of gas slowly form and the colour turns green. Identify the gas, write the equation, and justify the change with E∘.
(a) Oxidation states and species
From μ=n(n+2): 0, 1.73, 2.83 and 3.87 BM correspond to n=0,1,2,3 unpaired electrons. Vanadium is [Ar]3d34s2, with five electrons outside the argon core, so the number of d electrons left is 5−(oxidation state):
Stage
n
Configuration
Oxidation state
Species
P (yellow)
0
3d0
+5
VO2+
Q (blue)
1
3d1
+4
VO2+
R (green)
2
3d2
+3
V3+
S (violet)
3
3d3
+2
V2+
NCERT notes that oxygen stabilises V(V) as VO2+ and V(IV) as VO2+, and Table 4.8 lists V(IV) as blue, V3+ as green and V2+ as violet, which matches the observed colours.
(b) Why zinc stops at V2+
Zinc (Zn→Zn2+, couple −0.76 V) can reduce any couple lying above it: Ecell∘=E∘(vanadium couple)−(−0.76).
VO2+→VO2+:1.00+0.76=+1.76V
VO2+→V3+:0.34+0.76=+1.10V
V3+→V2+:−0.26+0.76=+0.50V
V2+→V:−1.18+0.76=−0.42V
The first three steps are spontaneous, but the last is not, so the reduction stops at violet V2+.
(c) Overall equation, P to S
Each V gains 3 electrons (+5 to +2) and each Zn loses 2, so 2 V need 3 Zn:
2VO2++3Zn+8H+→2V2++3Zn2++4H2O
Check: V 2, Zn 3, O 4, H 8 on each side; charge +2+8=+10 and +4+6=+10.
(d) Hydrogen from V2+
The gas is hydrogen. V2+ reduces H+ and becomes green V3+:
The positive value shows that the change is spontaneous. It happens only slowly, but that is a matter of rate, which E∘ does not predict. As it goes on, the moment of the vanadium falls from 3.87 BM to 2.83 BM.