(a) A and B. In A the CaCl2 removes water vapour, so there is oxygen but no water. In B, boiling has driven out the dissolved air and the oil stops more from dissolving, so there is water but no oxygen. The nail does not rust in either. So rusting needs both water and oxygen, as the electrochemical picture requires:
Anode: Fe→Fe2++2e−Cathode: O2+4H++4e−→2H2O
Water is the electrolyte that lets ions move between the anodic and cathodic spots, and oxygen is the oxidising agent that takes up the electrons.
(b) C < D < F.
- C rusts slowly: tap water contains few ions, so it is a poor electrolyte.
- D rusts faster: dissolved salt makes the water a good conductor, so the corrosion cells on the nail pass more current.
- F rusts fastest. Copper (+0.34 V) is less easily oxidised than iron (−0.44 V). The two metals in contact in salt water form a galvanic cell in which iron is the anode and copper is the cathode, where oxygen is reduced. This couple drives iron's oxidation even harder.
(c) In E the iron stays bright, while the zinc slowly corrodes. Zinc (−0.76 V) is more easily oxidised than iron (−0.44 V), so in contact with the nail zinc becomes the anode:
Zn→Zn2++2e−
The electrons flow into the iron, which becomes the cathode where oxygen is reduced, so iron itself is not oxidised. This is sacrificial protection. Tubes E and F show that the metal in contact with iron decides whether iron is protected (a metal below iron in the series) or attacked faster (a metal above it).