Question 564 marksHard
A village council debates whether to drain a wetland forest for a factory. (Hypothetical case.)
- Speaker P (villager): "The forest gives us firewood, fish, fibre for rope, and herbs for our medicines."
- Speaker Q (farmer downstream): "The wetland holds back floods that would otherwise ruin our fields."
- Speaker R (student): "Even the tiny frogs there, which are of no use to anyone, have a right to exist. We must hand this forest on to our children as we received it."
- Speaker S (developer): "Only things with a price tag count. The factory is worth more than the forest."
(a) Suppose cheap factory-made substitutes were found for every product that P mentions. Whose argument would this weaken, whose would it leave untouched, and why? Name the category of each argument in your answer. (2)
(b) Evaluate speaker S's claim, using NCERT's discussion of ecosystem services and of the ethical argument. (2)
