Grassland plots each held the same 12 plant species, named A to L. Researchers removed species from some plots and measured the fall in total plant biomass after three years. (Hypothetical data.)
Experiment 1: one species removed per plot
| Species removed | Fall in biomass |
|---|---|
| A, B, C, D, E or F (any one) | 1 to 4 per cent |
| G | 45 per cent |
| H to L (any one) | 2 to 5 per cent |
Experiment 2: species A to F removed one after another from the same plots
| Species removed so far | A | A, B | A to C | A to D | A to E | A to F |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total fall in biomass | 2% | 5% | 7% | 12% | 24% | 45% |
(a) Using Paul Ehrlich's analogy, identify which species behave like rivets on the wings and which like rivets on the seats. Justify your answer from Experiment 1. (1)
(b) Experiment 2 removed only "seat" species, yet the plots ended up as badly damaged as those that lost G. Describe the pattern in the data and explain it using the analogy. (2)
(c) A manager concludes from Experiment 1 alone: "Eleven of the twelve species hardly matter, so we can let them go." Evaluate this conclusion. (1)

