On a rocky sea coast of Scotland, the small barnacle Chthamalus is normally found only on the upper part of the shore. The larger barnacle Balanus dominates the middle part of the shore. Both live attached to the rock and compete for space on it. An experiment was done in the middle part of the shore. (Hypothetical data.)
| Plots | Treatment | Chthamalus cover at start (per cent) | Chthamalus cover after 1 year (per cent) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1–5 | Balanus left in place | 2 | 3 |
| 6–10 | Balanus removed | 2 | 38 |
(a) Describe what happened to Chthamalus in plots 6–10 and name this phenomenon.
(b) Which barnacle is competitively superior? Give evidence from the data.
(c) Why were plots 1–5 needed? How many times greater was the Chthamalus cover in plots 6–10 than in plots 1–5 after one year?
(d) What does this experiment show about why Chthamalus is usually restricted to the upper shore?

