An ecologist collected the results of many field experiments. In each one, a species was removed from some plots, and the r of a second species in the same group was compared between plots with and without the removed species. (Hypothetical data.)
| Group of organisms | Removal experiments | Experiments in which the second species' r was significantly higher after the removal |
|---|---|---|
| Plants | 40 | 26 |
| Herbivores | 30 | 18 |
| Carnivores | 30 | 6 |
(a) For each group, calculate the percentage of experiments that detected competition.
(b) Which NCERT generalisation about competition do these results support? Explain.
(c) Why is a rise in r after removal of the other species taken as evidence of competition?
(d) A student concludes: "Carnivores do not compete with one another, and plants suffer more from competition than herbivores do." Evaluate each half of this conclusion.
