Two wires P and Q are made of the same metal and have the same mass. Wire P has length and wire Q has length . The same load is hung from each wire, and both remain within the elastic limit.
What is the ratio of the extension of P to that of Q?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 47 of 80
Two wires P and Q are made of the same metal and have the same mass. Wire P has length and wire Q has length . The same load is hung from each wire, and both remain within the elastic limit.
What is the ratio of the extension of P to that of Q?
(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: Same metal and same mass means the same volume, . So the area is inversely proportional to the length: Q, being twice as long, has half the cross-sectional area of P.
Q stretches four times as much: twice because it is twice as long, and twice again because its stress is doubled by its halved area.
(B) is wrong: accounts for the doubled length but assumes the areas are equal; equal masses force Q to be thinner.
(C) is wrong: takes the area to scale as , as if the radius (rather than the area) were inversely proportional to the length.
(D) is wrong: the two wires have the same volume, but extension depends on how that volume is shared between length and area, not on the volume alone.