(a) In a metal, the atoms are held in place by strong forces from their neighbours. Stretching the metal means pulling every atom slightly farther from its neighbours; even a very small increase in their separation calls up a large restoring force. A large stress therefore produces only a tiny strain, which is what a large Y means.
(b) An elastomer is made of long chain molecules that are normally coiled and tangled. Stretching it mostly uncoils and straightens the chains rather than pulling atoms apart, which needs only small forces, so large strains come from small stresses. When the load is removed the chains return to their coiled arrangement and the material regains its length. As the chains become straighter it gets harder to stretch further, so the stress–strain curve is not a straight line and Hooke's law does not hold.