Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 47 of 80
A door is hinged about a vertical axis.
Question 471 markMCQHard
A door is hinged about a vertical axis. A force of the same magnitude is applied at the handle in four different ways:
I. vertically downwards;
II. horizontally, in the plane of the door, directed towards the hinge line;
III. horizontally, perpendicular to the plane of the door;
IV. horizontally, at 30∘ to the plane of the door.
Which of these forces have no turning effect about the hinge axis?
Select your answer
(A) II only
(B) I, II and IV
(C) I and II
Correct answer
(D) II and IV
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: For rotation about a fixed axis only the component of torque along the axis matters (the perpendicular components are balanced by the hinges). A force produces such a component only if it has a part that is perpendicular to the axis and whose line of action does not meet the axis. With r⊥ the distance of the handle from the hinge line:
I. The force is parallel to the axis. r×F is then perpendicular to the axis, so its component along the axis is zero; it only loads the hinges.
II. The line of action passes through the axis, so its perpendicular distance from the axis is zero: no turning effect.
III. The force is perpendicular to both the axis and the line from the axis to the handle, so the turning effect is the largest possible, r⊥F.
IV. The part of the force perpendicular to the door is Fsin30∘=F/2, which gives a turning effect r⊥F/2; the part along the door points at the hinge line and contributes nothing.
So only I and II have no turning effect.
(A) is wrong: it misses force I; a force parallel to the axis cannot turn the door about it.
(B) is wrong: force IV has a component perpendicular to the door and does turn it, with half the effect of III.
(D) is wrong: it includes IV, which turns the door, and leaves out I, which does not.