Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: The forces between the pucks are internal and the ice is smooth, so the total momentum, and hence the velocity of the centre of mass, is the same before, during and after the collision:
Vcm=1.5+2.51.5×4+2.5×0=46=1.5 m s−1
The kinetic energy of a system is the kinetic energy of motion of the centre of mass, 21MVcm2, plus the kinetic energy of motion about it. The first part cannot change, because Vcm cannot change:
K=21(1.5)(4)2=12 J,21MVcm2=21(4)(1.5)2=4.5 J
Only the energy of motion relative to the centre of mass, 12−4.5=7.5 J, can be lost. All of it is lost when the pucks stick together and move off at 1.5 m s−1; any other outcome loses less.
(A) is wrong: losing all 12 J would leave both pucks at rest, with zero total momentum, but the momentum 6 kg m s−1 must be conserved.
(C) is wrong: 4.5 J is the energy that must remain, the kinetic energy of the centre-of-mass motion, not the most that can be lost.
(D) is wrong: 10.3 J=12−21(1.5)(1.5)2 keeps only the first puck moving at Vcm and forgets that the 2.5 kg puck must also move at 1.5 m s−1 if they stick.