Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 44 of 80
A 1 kg trolley and a 4 kg trolley move on a level track with the same kinetic energy.
Question 441 markMCQHard
A 1 kg trolley and a 4 kg trolley move on a level track with the same kinetic energy. Each is brought to rest by the same constant retarding force F.
What is the ratio of their stopping distances, and the ratio of their stopping times (1 kg trolley : 4 kg trolley)?
Select your answer
(A) Distances 1:1; times 1:2
Correct answer
(B) Distances 1:4; times 1:2
(C) Distances 1:1; times 2:1
(D) Distances 4:1; times 1:1
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: Two different ideas are needed: work–energy for the distance and impulse–momentum for the time.
Distance: the retarding force removes all the kinetic energy, so Fs=K and s=K/F. Both trolleys have the same K and the same F, so the stopping distances are equal: 1:1.
Time: the force removes all the momentum, so Ft=p and t=p/F. With equal kinetic energy the momenta are not equal, because
p=2mK⇒p4p1=41=21
So t1:t4=1:2. For example, with K=50J and F=10N: both stop in 5 m; the 1 kg trolley (v=10m s−1, p=10kg m s−1) stops in 1 s, the 4 kg trolley (v=5m s−1, p=20kg m s−1) in 2 s.
(B) is wrong: the stopping distance depends on kinetic energy, not on mass, so it cannot be 1:4.
(C) is wrong: the lighter trolley is faster, but its momentum is smaller, so it stops in less time, not more.
(D) is wrong: equal kinetic energies under equal forces give equal distances, and the times differ because the momenta differ.