A sitar's main string is tuned to 147 Hz. A sympathetic string beneath it, never plucked, is tuned to 215 Hz. Each string is fixed at both ends. Using the normal modes of both strings, explain why the sympathetic string hardly responds when the main string is plucked. It is then retuned to 220.5 Hz. Show which of its modes is now driven strongly, and why its fundamental is still not driven.
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 80 of 80
A sitar's main string is tuned to 147 Hz.
Each string fixed at both ends has modes at whole-number multiples of its fundamental. The main string, when plucked, vibrates in a mixture of
and these reach the sympathetic string through the bridge as periodic driving forces. The sympathetic string responds strongly only when a driving frequency matches one of its own modes (resonance).
Tuned to 215 Hz, its modes are 215, 430, 645, 860, … Hz. Its fundamental is not a multiple of 147 Hz (); the nearest main-string harmonics, 147 Hz and 294 Hz, are 68 Hz and 79 Hz away. Its 2nd mode, 430 Hz, misses the main string's 3rd harmonic, 441 Hz, by 11 Hz, and its 4th mode, 860 Hz, misses the 6th harmonic, 882 Hz, by 22 Hz. None of the main string's strong low harmonics is close to any of its modes, so the response is weak.
Retuned to 220.5 Hz, its modes are 220.5, 441, 661.5, … Hz. Its 2nd mode is now exactly the main string's 3rd harmonic (), so it is driven at resonance (so are its 4th, 6th, … modes, 882 Hz, 1323 Hz, …, which equal the main string's 6th, 9th, … harmonics). The sympathetic string sounds 441 Hz, vibrating in two loops with a node at its midpoint. Its fundamental, 220.5 Hz, is still not driven: , so no whole-number harmonic of the main string equals it, and nothing pushes the string at that frequency.
