A pulse sent along a rope tied to a wall comes back upside down. A student argues that when he shouts at a cliff away, the echo should therefore come back "upside down" too and sound different. Explain what happens at the cliff and why the echo sounds the same as the shout. How long does the echo take to return? (Speed of sound .)
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 37 of 80
A pulse sent along a rope tied to a wall comes back upside down.
Both the wall and the cliff act as rigid boundaries. At the wall the rope cannot move, and at the cliff face the air cannot move into the rock, so in both cases the displacement at the boundary must stay zero. The reflected wave therefore has a phase change of : the rope pulse comes back inverted, and the air displacement in the echo is reversed in the same way.
The echo still sounds the same because a phase change of does not alter the frequency or the wavelength of the sound. Pitch depends on frequency, which is set by the source and is unchanged by reflection; the ear cannot detect a reversal of the displacement. The student is right that the reflection is inverted, but wrong that this changes what he hears.
The echo travels to the cliff and back, , so it returns after .
