Two astronauts stand apart on the Moon, which has no atmosphere. When one shouts inside her helmet, the other hears nothing, but they talk easily by radio. When they press their helmets together, they can hear each other faintly even with the radio switched off. Explain all three observations, and find how long a radio message takes to cross the 20 m gap and to reach Earth, away. ()
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 34 of 80
Two astronauts stand 20 m apart on the Moon, which has no atmosphere.
Shouting fails: sound is a mechanical wave and travels only through a material medium. The voice sets the air inside the helmet vibrating, but outside there is no air to pass the compressions and rarefactions on, so nothing reaches the other astronaut.
Radio works: radio waves are electromagnetic waves, which need no medium and travel through a vacuum at . Across the gap the delay is
which is far too short to notice (over 20 m of air, sound would take about ). A message to Earth takes , which is why conversations with mission control have a noticeable pause.
Helmets touching: the vibrations now pass from the air in one helmet, through the solid shells in contact, to the air in the other helmet. Mechanical waves travel through solids, so a continuous material path is all the sound needs.
