Two students send pulses of the same shape and size from opposite ends of a long stretched spring, one pulse upward and the other downward. At one instant the pulses overlap exactly and the spring looks completely straight. One student says the energy of the pulses has vanished for that instant. What actually happens to the energy at that instant?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 12 of 80
Two students send pulses of the same shape and size from opposite ends of a long stretched spring, one pulse upward…
(A) The energy is momentarily zero and is created again as the pulses separate
(B) All the energy is stored as elastic potential energy because the spring is straight
(C) The energy has passed to the hands of the two students and comes back later
- Correct answer
(D) All the energy is kinetic, because the elements of the spring are still moving
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: By the principle of superposition the displacements of the two pulses add, and at the instant of exact overlap they cancel everywhere, so the spring is straight. The velocities of the elements do not cancel, however. In the upward pulse moving one way, the elements on its leading half are moving up; in the downward pulse moving the other way, the corresponding elements are also moving up, so the velocities add. A straight spring is not stretched beyond its normal state, so there is no extra elastic energy at that instant; the whole energy of the two pulses is present as kinetic energy of the moving elements. A moment later these moving elements carry the spring out into the two separated pulses again, each with its original shape.
Option (A) is wrong: energy cannot disappear and reappear; the pulses re-emerge unchanged precisely because their energy is still in the spring as kinetic energy.
Option (B) is wrong: elastic potential energy is stored where the spring is bent and stretched; a straight spring at that instant has none of the pulses' potential energy.
Option (C) is wrong: the pulses are in the middle of the spring, far from the ends, so no energy has gone back to the students' hands; the energy is in the spring near the overlap.
