(a) The mass of oxygen is the mass of oxide minus the mass of carbon. For X:
Exp. 1: 0.902.10−0.90=0.901.20=1.33,Exp. 2: 2.104.90−2.10=2.102.80=1.33
Different amounts of carbon combine with oxygen in the same mass ratio, 1.33 g of oxygen per gram of carbon, so X has a fixed composition: the law of definite proportions.
(b) For Y, 1.505.50−1.50=1.504.00=2.67 g of oxygen per gram of carbon. For a fixed mass of carbon, the masses of oxygen in X and Y are in the ratio
1.33:2.67=1:2
a ratio of small whole numbers: the law of multiple proportions.
(c) In CO, one carbon atom (12 u) combines with one oxygen atom (16 u): 16/12=1.33, matching X. In CO2, one carbon atom combines with two oxygen atoms: 32/12=2.67, matching Y. If a compound consists of identical molecules, each with a fixed number of atoms of fixed mass, then any sample of it has the same mass ratio (definite proportions). And since atoms combine only in whole numbers (one or two oxygen atoms per carbon atom, never one and a half), the oxygen masses for a fixed carbon mass must be in a ratio of small integers (multiple proportions).