Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: Assertion (A) is true. In a solid each atom vibrates about its mean position in three dimensions. By the law of equipartition of energy, an oscillation in one dimension has average energy 2×21kBT=kBT (kinetic plus potential), so each atom has 3kBT and one mole of atoms has
U=3kBT×NA=3RT
The volume of a solid hardly changes on heating, so the heat needed per kelvin is C=ΔU/ΔT=3R=24.9 J mol−1 K−1 for every such solid, whatever the mass of its atoms. The measured values, about 24.4 J mol−1 K−1 for aluminium and 26.4 J mol−1 K−1 for lead, are indeed close to each other and to 3R.
Reason (R) is also true: the molar masses are 27.0 g mol−1 and 207.2 g mol−1, so a lead atom is 207.2/27.0=7.7 times as massive as an aluminium atom.
But R does not explain A. The mass of an atom does not enter C=3R at all; the heat needed per mole depends only on the number of atoms and the energy each one takes up. R explains a different fact: per kilogram, aluminium needs about 7.7 times as much heat as lead (3R/M gives 923 against 120 J kg−1 K−1), because a kilogram of aluminium contains 7.7 times as many atoms.
(A) is wrong: R, though true, is not the reason the molar heats are nearly equal; they are nearly equal in spite of the very different atomic masses.
(C) is wrong: R is true; the atomic masses differ by a factor of about 7.7.
(D) is wrong: both statements are true.