A horizontal cylinder with insulating walls is divided into two parts by a piston that slides without friction but does not let heat through. The piston is at rest, with the gas on the left at and the gas on the right at . Which state variable must be the same on the two sides, and can the two temperatures stay different like this? What would happen if the piston were replaced by one that conducts heat well?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 39 of 80
A horizontal cylinder with insulating walls is divided into two parts by a piston that slides without friction but…
The piston is at rest only when the net force on it is zero. The two gases push on its two faces of equal area , so : the pressures must be equal (mechanical equilibrium). The temperatures can still be different. The piston acts as an adiabatic wall, which does not allow heat to flow, so the gas at and the gas at can stay at those temperatures indefinitely; equal pressure does not mean equal temperature.
If the piston conducts heat (a diathermic wall), heat flows through it from the gas at to the gas at . The piston keeps moving so that the pressures stay equal while the hotter gas cools and the cooler gas warms. The flow stops only when the two temperatures are equal. The final state has both the same pressure and the same temperature on the two sides: the gases are then in thermal as well as mechanical equilibrium.
