An engineer proposes to change the Carnot cycle. Instead of an adiabatic expansion to cool the gas from to , she would hold the volume fixed and put the gas in contact with the cold reservoir until it cools to (and similarly heat it at constant volume with the hot reservoir later). Explain why her engine would no longer be a reversible engine working between only two temperatures.
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 38 of 80
An engineer proposes to change the Carnot cycle.
For a step to be reversible, heat must never flow across a finite temperature difference. When the gas at is put in contact with the cold reservoir at , heat flows from the gas to the reservoir while their temperatures differ, so this step is not quasi-static and cannot be reversed. To change the temperature at constant volume reversibly, she would need a whole series of reservoirs at every temperature between and , and then the engine would no longer work between just two temperatures. An adiabatic step exchanges no heat with any reservoir, so it can change the gas's temperature from to (and back) reversibly. That is why the Carnot cycle uses two isothermal steps joined by two adiabatic ones.
