Four situations are described below. Which one would violate the Clausius statement of the second law of thermodynamics?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 14 of 80
Four situations are described below. Which one would violate the Clausius statement of the second law of thermodynamics?
- Correct answer
(A) An unpowered box that cools a can of juice below room temperature by passing heat from the juice into the warmer room, with no other change anywhere
(B) A block of ice at giving heat to liquid nitrogen at that is poured over it
(C) A refrigerator, driven by an electric motor, passing heat from its cold inside to the warmer kitchen
(D) A hot stone at dropped into a bucket of water at and cooling down
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: The Clausius statement says: no process is possible whose sole result is the transfer of heat from a colder object to a hotter object. In (A) heat goes from the cooler juice to the warmer room, and nothing else happens: no work is supplied and no other change takes place. That is exactly what the statement forbids, even though energy would be conserved.
(B) is wrong: ice at is hotter than liquid nitrogen at , so the heat flows from hotter to colder; "cold" in everyday language does not decide the direction, the temperatures do.
(C) is wrong: heat goes from cold to hot, but this is not the sole result, since the motor does work on the refrigerator.
(D) is wrong: heat flows spontaneously from the hotter stone to the colder water, as the second law allows.
