A patent office receives four claims. Which one must be rejected because it violates the Kelvin–Planck statement of the second law of thermodynamics?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 13 of 80
A patent office receives four claims.
(A) An engine that, in each cycle, takes of heat from a furnace, does of work and gives out of heat to cooling water
(B) A refrigerator that, using electrical work, takes heat from food inside it and gives out a larger amount of heat to the kitchen
(C) A room heater that turns of electrical work entirely into heat each minute
- Correct answer
(D) A sealed engine on a satellite that, cycle after cycle, absorbs heat from a single hot plate and delivers an equal amount of mechanical work, with no other change anywhere
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: The Kelvin–Planck statement says: no process is possible whose sole result is the absorption of heat from a reservoir and the complete conversion of the heat into work. Device (D) runs in cycles, so at the end of each cycle the engine is back in its initial state; the only result is that heat from one reservoir (the hot plate) has become an equal amount of work. That is exactly what the statement forbids, even though energy is conserved.
(A) is wrong: this engine rejects heat to a colder body (the cooling water); converting only part of the heat into work is allowed.
(B) is wrong: heat moves from cold food to the warmer kitchen, but only with electrical work done on the refrigerator, which is allowed.
(C) is wrong: Kelvin–Planck forbids turning heat entirely into work, not work entirely into heat. Converting electrical work completely into heat is what every heater does.
