In a severe winter, the surface of a deep mountain lake has frozen over, but fish are still swimming near the bottom. A diver lowers a thermometer to the bed of the lake. Which reading should she expect, and why?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 9 of 80
In a severe winter, the surface of a deep mountain lake has frozen over, but fish are still swimming near the bottom.
(A) , because the water touching the ice is at its freezing point and the whole lake settles to that temperature
(B) Below , because the coldest water is the densest and sinks to the bottom
- Correct answer
(C) About , because water is densest at , so the water at this temperature sinks and stays at the bottom
(D) About , because ice is a good conductor of heat and passes heat from the air down to the bottom
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: As the air cools the surface water, that water becomes denser and sinks, and convection mixes the lake. This continues only until the water reaches , where water has its greatest density. Water cooled below becomes less dense, so it stays at the top; it is this top layer that cools to and freezes. The densest water, at about , collects at the bottom. Convection has stopped, and the ice and the cold water above are poor conductors, so the bottom water loses heat very slowly and the fish survive.
(A) is wrong: the lake is not at one temperature. Only the water just under the ice is at ; the colder top water is lighter and cannot sink to mix with the bottom water.
(B) is wrong: water below is less dense, not more; liquid water below would not collect at the bottom.
(D) is wrong: the reading is right but the reason is not. Ice is a poor conductor (about ), and in any case the air above is colder than the water, so no heat flows down through the ice.
