(a) [E]=[ML2T−2], [m]=[M], [c]=[LT−1].
[ML2T−2]=[M]a[LT−1]b=[MaLbT−b]
- M: a=1
- L: b=2
- T: −b=−2, which agrees with b=2.
So E=kmc2. The method cannot give the value of k.
(b) Try E=kmacbvd. Since c and v both have dimensions [LT−1], the dimensional equation becomes
[ML2T−2]=[MaLb+dT−(b+d)]
This gives only a=1 and b+d=2: two unknowns in one equation. Any choice works, so E=kmcbv2−b for every value of b (for example mc2, mcv or mv2). The method cannot tell apart quantities that have the same dimensions, so it gives no unique answer; the ratio v/c is dimensionless and could appear in any power or function.