When water flows through a pipe of radius , the flow stays smooth only up to a critical speed , given by
where is the viscosity of the liquid, defined by ( tangential force, area, velocity gradient), its density, and is a number called the Reynolds number.
(a) Show that is dimensionless.
(b) A student writes the formula as . Use dimensions to show this form cannot be right.
(c) Another textbook writes , where is the diameter of the pipe. Is this form dimensionally acceptable? How are and related, and why can dimensional analysis not find either of them?
